An Original Farmhouse is Sold in Greenacres

One of Scarsdale’s original farmhouses has recently sold. The house at 6 Donellan Road in Greenacres was built in 1899 and was known as the Donellan Estate. The property originally included 7 acres of orchards that were sold off to the Robert Farley Organization during the 1920’s to form 26 lots making up the neighborhood we now enjoy. The quiet street still feels like a country lane but is within walking distance of the Scarsdale train station.The house has been restored but still includes many period details including a grand entry porch, moldings, high ceilings, arched doorways and a wood paneled library. The 14-room home is 4,640 square feet on three stories with 6 bedrooms.

Map: Courtesy of the Scarsdale Historical SocietyThis map from 1910 shows that the original 7.4 acre estate owned by A.V. Donellan was sandwiched between the 6.8 acre James Brite estate and the 3.7 acre H.D. Brewster estate which were all subdivided by the time of the 1930’s map of Greenacres above.

Also take a look at the ad for the original sale of the house which advertises a “Beautiful All-Year Country Residence in Scarsdale.” It describes a home with features like “electric light and gas,” and “a stable water supply.” It also says the surrounding orchards supply “plenty of fruit in good variety.” About the commute to the city it says, “Forty minutes from Grand Central” with “forty trains each way daily.”

Most recently, the house was listed for $2,999,000 by Angela Retelny of Compass Real Estate who said, “We are so honored and excited to represent the sellers of a true Scarsdale gem. A rare and magnificent Victorian with a dreamy front porch and extraordinary character. The location on Donellan Road, a quiet enclave on the heart of Greenacres, made this offering even more special. The property attracted lots of viewings and interest. We are happy to report the property is now in contract!”

Sales This Week: 

14 Windmill Lane  Fabulous Greenacres Colonial in the prestigious Grange estate section of Scarsdale. Situated in the highly-acclaimed Scarsdale School District, this modern home is a short walk to the elementary school, offering unparalleled convenience and luxury. This spacious residence is perfect for both everyday living and formal entertaining, featuring large rooms, high ceilings and a perfect layout plus an expansive deck and private backyard. The first level welcomes you with a double-height entry foyer leading to a formal living room with a stunning gray marble fireplace surround and bay window. The formal dining room is ideal for hosting elegant gatherings. The modern eat-in-kitchen boasts a large island, white cabinetry, quartzite countertops, 2023 Thermador/Wolf appliances and sliders to the deck for seamless indoor-outdoor living. Adjoining the kitchen is a large family room with glass pocket doors. A mudroom with a side door to the deck, guest room/office with full bath ensuite and French door to the deck, a powder room and a two-car garage complete this level. Upstairs, the second level features a spacious primary bedroom with a luxurious ensuite bathroom complete with a jetted soaking tub, double vanity, radiant heated floors, curbless shower and private WC. Two walk-in closets and a relaxing lounge area add to this sumptuous retreat. Three additional generous bedrooms each have their own beautiful ensuite bathroom. This level also includes a laundry room and some versatile finished storage space. The lower level offers a large recreation room, which can accommodate a playroom, gym and media room or whatever your heart desires. This home is in impeccable condition throughout - just move in and start enjoying the 30-minute commute to Grand Central Terminal on Metro North and all Scarsdale has to offer! Don't miss this exceptional property.
Sale Price: $3,801,000
Real Estate Taxes: $46,602
Assessment Value: $1,750,000

14 Kolbert Drive  Welcome to this stately center hall colonial on level half acre in stunning Murdock woods. This house needs updating, sold strictly As Is. Recent updates include the roof, Central Air Conditioning, Heating system and hot water tank.
Sale Price: $1,755,000
Real Estate Taxes: $33,230
Assessment Value: $1,479,000

10 Crossway  This beautifully updated colonial features 4 bedrooms and 3.5 baths, offering a perfect blend of classic charm and modern convenience. The first level has a formal dining room, a spacious living room, and a cozy family room with a fireplace. It also includes a mudroom and a laundry room. The eat-in kitchen has stainless appliances and is equipped with a Pella sliding door that leads to a 900 sqft Gossen PVC deck with Azek railing, ideal for outdoor gatherings. The fenced backyard ensures privacy and is great for play. On the second floor, the master bedroom serves as a private retreat with a walk-in closet and an en-suite bathroom. There are also three additional bedrooms and a hallway bath. The fully finished basement offers nearly 1100 sqft of versatile space with a brand new floor, perfect for an entertainment area or playroom, and includes ample storage and a full bath. Recent updates include fresh paint, new roof, LED lightings, a full-house generator, and a Tesla charger. The property features a circular driveway and a two-car garage with a Gladiator storage system.

Sale Price: $1,720,000
Real Estate Taxes: $18,668
Assessment Value: $1,025,000

17 Wyndham Road  Impressive 1927-built Tudor with 4 bedrooms, 3.5 baths, situated on a .31-acre lot with a beautiful in-ground pool in the heart of the highly-acclaimed Edgemont school system. Owned by a local architect and exuding high-quality craftsmanship and exquisite details throughout, the home boasts an original and beautifully-maintained Ludowici red tile roof, exposed beams, and an art-deco style mantle in the living room. Enjoy resort-style living with a breezy screened porch and a lovely roof deck, both overlooking the recently relined pool, perfect for entertaining family and friends poolside all summer long. The first level offers a charming entry foyer with a powder room and coat closet, a step-down formal living room featuring a high ceiling with exposed beams, a stunning art-deco style wood-burning fireplace, and original French doors leading to the screened porch with a view of the lush property and pool. The formal dining room includes original built-in shelves and cabinetry. The modern, white eat-in kitchen with a bay window is complemented by a den and laundry room, which may possibly be opened up to expand the kitchen area or converted back to a bedroom and full bath. A side door near the kitchen leads to a path with a BBQ with a natural gas line. The second level boasts a primary suite with a tray ceiling and views of the property, two closets with double-hanging, and an ensuite full bath with lovely original stained-glass windows. Additionally, there is a bedroom with an ensuite full bath, two bedrooms sharing a jack-and-jill bath, and a large landing with a French door leading to a roof deck overlooking the property. This level also includes a linen closet, a cedar closet, and access to the attic via Bessler stairs, providing excellent storage and potential for expansion. The lower level features a large, above-ground recreation room with a very high ceiling, a wood-burning fireplace, and a French door to a patio and the backyard. The storage/utility room includes a newly installed furnace and hot water heater (2024). The fabulous pool, situated on a separate tax lot (0 Wyndham Rd), is fenced with two gates for access.(Taxes listed include both lots.) It was relined, the filter motor replaced in June 2024, and it has a new winter cover from 2022. The pool is piped for heat, but the heat is not operational and can be restored by the buyer. The flat roof over the screened porch was replaced in 2024. The home features central air in the kitchen, den, and lower-level recreation room, and window units in two of the bedrooms. The house was re-insulated in 2023 with blown-in insulation in the attic and most exterior walls.
Sale Price: $1,650,000
Real Estate Taxes: $33,206
Assessment Value: $1,030,800

255 Healy Avenue  Calling all renovation enthusiasts, come check out this charming Edgemont home with terrific potential. This spacious property features a large living room, large family room, large primary bedroom with ensuite bath, and oversized enclosed porch. The indoor/outdoor flow is perfect for gatherings, and the bonus room works well as a separate office space or playroom. This home is ideal for those looking to customize and update to their taste. Don't miss this opportunity to create your dream home in the sought-after Edgemont School District. ZILLOW HAS ERRONEOUS INFORMATION THIS HOUSE IS NOT A FORECLOSURE.
Sale Price: $880,000
Real Estate Taxes: $19,404
Assessment Value: $721,300

Featured Listings:

7 Roosevelt Place  Stunning storybook Tudor perfectly located across the street from Edgewood Elementary School and just a short stroll to downtown Scarsdale shops and the Metro North train for a 32 minute commute to Grand Central Terminal. This beautifully built 1929 home has been lovingly cared for by the current owners for over 50 years. The spacious first level features a vestibule leading to a gracious foyer, fabulous formal living room with a double-height cathedral ceiling and impressive wood-burning fireplace, formal dining room with original built-in cabinetry and Juliet balcony doors, large open plan kitchen/family room with a dining area and French doors to the patio and yard, bedroom/office with a half bath, den/office and a laundry/mudroom accessible from a side entry to the house. The second level boasts a primary bedroom with a walk-in closet, two additional closets and a large en-suite bathroom with a separate tub and shower. Two large bedrooms and a hall bath complete this level. The unfinished lower level includes versatile space, storage and a Bilco egress door. The patio is generously sized and boasts outdoor lighting and access to a level, private backyard and the detached two car garage. Full house generator included. Entire interior freshly painted, stucco exterior power washed and all new light fixtures. This home is in an A+ location, only a short walk to the High School and across the street from Edgewood Elementary School in the highly-acclaimed Scarsdale school district. You can easily walk down or take the public bus to the Scarsdale downtown shops, restaurants and train station. Take advantage of all Scarsdale has to offer including an outdoor public pool complex, town tennis courts and a weekly farmer's market when you make this Edgewood gem your home!
Click here for more information:

Listing Price: $1,425,000 

102 Potter Road  Move right in to this completely renovated (2016), three bedroom Scarsdale Colonial that feels brand new. Bright and open layout perfect for today's buyer with a gorgeous high end kitchen with white cabinetry, stainless appliances, marble counters and island/breakfast bar. Completing the first level - there is an expansive sunlit living room with brick fireplace, cozy front sitting area, large dining area and powder room. The primary bedroom has a cathedral ceiling with a luxurious en-suite bath and walk-in closet. Two bedrooms with a modern hall bath complete the 2nd level. There is additional square footage (approximately 529 SF not included) in the basement with lots of potential for an exercise or playroom. This fantastic home has a young modern vibe, lots of windows with light streaming in and lush green views. Under a majestic canopy of trees, the backyard has a nice stone patio and is great to relax, play and entertain with easy access from the home. This spectacular location is a quick walk to Scarsdale village, train and elementary school. It is also less than a 5 minutes drive to Equinox, Trader Joe's and Vernon Hills Shopping Center! You will fall in love with this rare gem - it has everything to make it a convenient and wonderful home!
Click here for more information:

Listing Price: $1,050,000