Shout it Out

Details: Published: 02 August 2010; Created: 02 August 2010; Last Updated: 03 August 2010; Hits: 5908

The New York State Education Department just released test scores of proficiency tests in math and English given to all 3rd through 8th graders in New York public schools last spring. For months prior to the release of the scores, the State Education Commissioner, David Steiner dithered about whether to adjust the "cut scores" -- or the baseline for determining proficiency on these tests. Apparently research has shown that the New York State tests were not adequately measuring proficiency in math and English. But instead of methodically, collaboratively, and smartly revising and implementing new, more rigorous assessments, the Commissioner and the New York State Board of Regents decided to arbitrarily, retro-actively raise the proficiency bar for the tests already taken. As a result -- the "proficiency" level of students in New York has plummeted through the floor -- all across the state -- from poor urban school districts to the wealthiest lily white school districts. According to the New York Times, "The falloff in passing rates occurred statewide. This year, 61 percent of state students were deemed passing, or at grade level, in math, compared with 86 percent last year. Students also performed dismally on the English tests, with 53 percent passing, down from 77 percent.”

This act by the commissioner and the Regents comes well after school districts created and adopted their budgets for the succeeding school year -- and they clearly have no way to fund the deluge of mandated remediation. For those students not attaining proficiency, the state mandates "academic intervention services". There's no way for school districts to now fund for the massive influx of required additional services for the upcoming school year. Also, as a result of the arbitrary cut score adjustment -- many more schools will fail to show "adequate yearly progress" required under the federal No Child Left Behind law. But the state education department in its infinite wisdom is seeking an exception this year due to the drop in proficiency. The department is also granting a one-time exemption for school districts from the additional remediation requirement.

So why do this at all?

Education Commissioner Steiner and Regents Chancellor Tisch said research shows the existing tests had failed to accurately predict whether or not students were truly proficient or whether they would be ready for high school or college coursework. “What has changed is that we are setting the bar higher,” said Tisch. “The same score that got you over bar last year is not enough to get you over the bar this year.”

How stupid is that?

There are an infinite battery of testing regimens out there. In fact, according to Newsday, some Long Island districts have been pining to use readily available assessments that are deemed far superior to the New York State tests to determine proficiency levels. These test results are also available immediately. They want permission to use a testing regimen developed by the Norwest Evaluation Association: “We believe the NWEA gives us more information and better information and . . . teachers don’t have to sit around waiting for results,” said William Johnson, superintendent in Rockville Centre, a district involved in the push for alternative testing. http://bit.ly/9cLIQ0

Look, it's fine to raise the bar -- raise the standards -- raise the expectations – and then design tests that measure what you want to measure. This act by the commissioner and the Regents defies common sense. So now you have the spectacle of everyone bemoaning the quality of our public schools -- and the post-budgeting scramble to put together remediation programs for the additional non-proficient students -- while the state education department -- says “oops we goofed -- and please give us a bye on Adequate Yearly Progress.”

So why was this done? It’s the Race to the Top.

The Race to the Top has turned our educational leaders into groveling lap dogs pathetically begging for a slab of beef (or a piece of $700 million).

Chancellor Tisch and State Education Commissioner David Steiner are front and center on this pull the rug out, knee-jerk, illusory suck up to Education Secretary Arne Duncan and the Race to the Top dollars. Tisch has been a Regent since 1996 -- and she just now deigns that the statewide testing regimen is deficient? Here's what she had to say:

We haven’t been testing the right things in the right ways. ‘Proficiency’ on our exams has to mean something real; no good purpose is served when we say that a child is proficient when that child is not. So we’re improving our assessments by raising cut scores, making the exams less predictable, testing more areas, and making the tests longer. But more rigorous exams are only one piece of the Regents broader reform vision – a vision that includes a more challenging curriculum, better training for teachers and principals, and a world-class data system.

You have got to be kidding! You’re not improving your assessment by raising cut scores!

And this is yet another massive unfunded mandate that the state has foisted up on school districts and the property tax payer.

Chancellor Tisch has been a Regent since 1996 – and has had an oversight role on the New York State educational bureaucracy for the better part of 15 years. Merryl Tisch should resign as Chancellor -- and Commissioner David Steiner should be fired. This post-hoc cut score change is a pernicious act of assault on schools, students, parents and teachers in New York State. The Regents and the commissioner have shown that they are clueless about education and the ways and means to reform teaching and instruction.

David A. Singer is a former political consultant/campaign professional and political junkie currently toiling as a lawyer in Westchester and managing real estate and media investments.

Details: Published: 28 July 2010; Created: 28 July 2010; Last Updated: 28 July 2010; Hits: 5605

This summer I have been interning for Sean Coffey, one of the five Democratic candidates running for New York State Attorney General (now that Cuomo is giving up his position to run for Governor). Going in to the internship, I wasn’t entirely sure what to expect from it, or even what I was going to think of Sean as a candidate. The job ended up being a very hands-on and engaging internship. All of the interns were given a lot of responsibility, and we were almost always doing tasks that were visibly important to the campaign.

I learned an enormous amount about politics this summer. While I understand that I may seem biased, I genuinely believe Sean Coffey is the best candidate for the job of Attorney General based on what I have observed and learned these past few months.

The four other Democratic candidates in the primary are veterans to politics: State Assemblyman Richard Brodsky, Nassau County District Attorney Kathleen Rice, State Senator Eric Schneiderman, and former Superintendent of Insurance Eric Dinallo. Sean Coffey is a complete political newcomer, and, given the total dysfunction of our state’s government right now, this is a true asset to his campaign. He proudly says in interviews that one of the things that makes him such a strong candidate is, in fact, his lack of political experience. Sean Coffey as New York’s Attorney General would bring a breath of fresh air to Albany, something that is long overdue.

Sean has a very impressive background. He was born in the Bronx to Irish-immigrant parents and is the oldest of seven children. He grew up in a union household and moved around a great deal during his childhood. Sean attended the US Naval Academy and graduated in 1978. He served in the Navy for 8 years on active duty and for 18 years as a reservist. While stationed in Washington D.C., he attended Georgetown Law at night. Later he moved to New York to begin practicing law. He was an associate with Paul Weiss Rifkind Wharton and Garrison and then became an Assistant United States Attorney for the Southern District. After several years, he joined Latham and Watkins as a corporate defense attorney, but then later returned to being a plaintiff’s attorney at the firm Bernstein Litowitz. During his years at Bernstein Litowitz, Sean led some of the most successful class action law suits in recent years, including the litigation against WorldComm in which the team recovered billions of dollars on behalf of defrauded investors and historically made WorldComm’s directors, officers, and others pay personally for their wrongdoing.

Sean is more than qualified to be our state’s top lawyer, but beyond that, he has proven his dedication to the position by pledging never to run for higher office (i.e. what Spitzer did and what Cuomo is now doing by running for governor). Sean Coffey truly wants to be the next Attorney General and clean up Albany’s corruption, get the government functioning once again, and protect the state of New York. He’s released several agendas explaining his positions on various issues, and those can be found at his website www.coffey2010.com

If you are a registered Democrat, when September 14th comes around, I really encourage you to consider Sean Coffey as the next Attorney General.

Details: Published: 08 July 2010; Created: 08 July 2010; Last Updated: 08 July 2010; Hits: 6271

If you have experienced a dip in your water pressure, here is an explanation from Scarsdale Village Manager Al Gatta, about what is happenig with our supply:

According to Al, " The Village is experiencing water pressure problems as are many water utilities for three basic reasons:

1- The City of New York is delayed in repairing a main feeder line to the Village of Scarsdale that was scheduled to be completed on June 5, 2010;

2 -The Village has about a six-month delay in the upgrade of the Ardsley Road Pump Station because of environmental factors not anticipated in the original specifications. For example, PCBs in the paint from the 1950’s, large amounts of lead in the paint and more extensive work related to the removal of asbestos. Current environmental regulations require absolute removal of these potential hazardous items.

3-The mandatory lawn water restriction imposed by the Village Board has not been successful in curtailing the watering of lawns from 1am until 8:30am.

There were two fires in White Plains on July 7 which caused great havoc in the Village in regard to the water use and pressure. The electrical substation in White Plains was shut down and damaged because of the fire that impacted the water pumps at the Reeves Newsome Station. That station supplies water to all of Scarsdale and had to be operated on emergency generation that does not pack the energy to maintain water pressure. Thus, some residents had very little water for a short period of time.

In addition, the fire on Post Road in White Plains was a big one that forced the City of White Plains to use 25 million gallons of water which is twice their usual summer water usage of approximately 12 million gallons per day. This reduced the water volume and pressure to Scarsdale. In regard to general summer consumption, we are not pleased with the continued use of high volumes of water for lawn watering and the lack of compliance with mandatory restrictions imposed by the Village Board. The restrictions are on the Village’s web page."

In addition to the lawn watering restrictions imposed by Scarsdale, residents are also being asked to conserve water by Westchester County. Due to work that the New York City Department of Environmental Protection (NYCDEP) is doing inside the Kensico Dam there are limitations on supply. During the construction we are receiving our water from a diversion system that was set up by the NYCDEP. The fire in White Plains on July 7 put additional strain on resources so residents are being asked to cut back usage.

If usage is too high, it could result in reduced water pressure, disruptions in service and possible mandatory restrictions, similar to those put in place in drought situations.

Construction began last year and will last through the fall. As water consumption usually increases during the summer months, conservation is more critical now. Peak water usage also occurs during the early morning hours each day. To reduce water usage, residents have been asked to:

Limit lawn watering
Take shorter showers
Fix leaks
Avoid unnecessary toilet flushes
Refrain from running water while shaving or brushing your teeth

Additional tips on water conservation can be found at: www.westchestergov.com/wateragency. And if you have questions, contact the Westchester County Water Agency at (914) 995-4425.

Details: Published: 20 July 2010; Created: 20 July 2010; Last Updated: 20 July 2010; Hits: 5205

The ad hoc Heathcote Five Corners Traffic committee was formed to look into how to ease the flow of vehicular and pedestrian traffic through the busy intersection at Heathcote Road, Palmer Avenue, Wilmot Road, and Weaver Street. Residents are frustrated with the waiting time to pass through the intersection, and the Heathcote Five Corners Coalition was formed to “relieve and reduce traffic congestion and improve pedestrian safety” at the Heathcote Five Corners.

With even more development in the offing, the situation is only expected to get worse. Nine new homes are currently under construction at Heathcote Manor, situated on Weaver Street, east of the circle. In addition, an 11,000 square foot retail building is planned for 1 Palmer Avenue for the corner of Heathcote and Palmer Roads on the site of the gas station and the owners of the Heathcote Tavern Building have applied to reopen the restaurant and made several proposals to further develop the old tavern building.

The Traffic committee has recommended that the Village put out an RFP to engineering firms to do a feasibility study of installing a five-legged traffic circle, including a survey, and engineering and traffic analyses. The cost of the study is estimated to be $25,000 to $30,000.

A similar roundabout has been built in Glens Falls, New York, and you can click here to see how it works:

Do you think a traffic circle would do the trick? Share your views below!

Details: Published: 07 July 2010; Created: 07 July 2010; Last Updated: 07 July 2010; Hits: 5262

On a buggy Friday night, members of the Scarsdale community of all ages flocked to the Scarsdale pool to celebrate an early Fourth of July. While the actual fireworks show did not start until 9 PM, people arrived much earlier to stake out a good location at the pool and a decent parking spot as well. With card and sports games to keep occupied, lounge and beach chairs to stay comfortable, and snacks and ice cream trucks to stay full, everyone was ready for the show. And, as always by the end of it, everyone left happy (if you forget about the bug bites you’ll be scratching for the next week)! Happy 4th!
Contributor Nell Brodsky is a 2009 alum of Scarsdale High School who just completed her first year at Brown.