Should Fishing Be Permitted in Scarsdale?

Is fishing legal in Scarsdale? That's the question now that the activity has become popular at Library Pond, which is home to largemouth bass, bluegills, carp and some enormous snapping turtles. Local dad, Brian Culang and his son were turned away from the pond by Scarsdale Police who said that fishing was not allowed. Culang questioned the rule as he thinks fishing is a healthy activity, preferable to playing video games inside, and appears to be harmless.

Below is a letter he wrote to the Scarsdale Police and Rec Department to find out more:

I recently visited Harwood Park with my son, who brought along a freshwater fishing rod to enjoy the afternoon outdoors. However, we were approached by SPD and informed that fishing was not allowed at that location due to Village code. (The officer could not have been more professional and we appreciate his service to be clear!)

I reviewed the Scarsdale Village Code but could not find any specific regulation prohibiting fishing in town. Could you please direct me to the relevant section that restricts this activity? 

I did notice a sign posted at the park that reads "No Fishing"; it appears to be unofficial, lacking any Scarsdale or NY state markings.

I would like to ensure that we are not enforcing rules that actually aren't on the books! And if there is a town code against fishing, the good news is that I think I found a meaningful civic project for me and my son to work on together!

Thank you for your assistance.

Best regards,
Brian Culang